Comments on: Revolver Vs. Auto for CCW?

By: Motor-T

Motor-T — Fri, 04 Jan 2013 20:27:33 +0000

One of the aspects of the revolver vs auto debate that is rarely discussed is trigger weight. Most factory new revolvers have a 10-12lb triggers. Many modern service pistols have 5-7 lb triggers. All other things being equal a lighter trigger is easier to shoot accurately, and many shooters will shoot a modern semi auto more accurately than a revolver.

By: SmithKoWitz

SmithKoWitz — Thu, 30 Aug 2012 02:12:18 +0000

I thought you were starting an argument? Personally, I carry a semi-auto most all the time. Varies between an LCP, Kahr MK40, SAEMP40 & Kimber SCHDPRO; mostly carry the 2nd & 3rd listed and sometimes the LCP as backup. As for Revolvers, I would actually say I think too that they are more reliable (not that I’ve had any trouble with any of the guns mentioned), but revolvers are simple. The only issue I ever had were rounds that must have had to a high a pressure and they did not want to eject (they were factory rounds too). The sad part, it was a J frame model 632 327magnum. Never had any trouble with my model 686+ or 629, but they are a little on the large side for CCW; except in colder months. When I find a holster I like I just might start carrying the 686+ with the 3″ barrel. I actually find it extremely accurate and quicker for follow up shots that are accurate compared to most semi-autos. I also don’t notice accuracy variances with different brands of ammo as I do with semi-autos. Yep, I like my 7 shot 357/38 if you desire, but it’s a bit hefty; so are the EMP and the Kimber SCHDPRO. The model 632 327magnum is a nasty little bugger for recoil, I can only imagine what a 357 must be like in a J frame (never shot one, yet) or a Scandium J frame, even better . . .

By: Bill

Bill — Tue, 28 Aug 2012 00:39:35 +0000

My two favorite handguns for CCW use are a S&W Model 442 with its concealed hammer and a Kahr CW40. Both have Crimson Trace laser sights and are loaded witht he best JHP ammo I can find in either .38 Special +P or .40 S&W caliber. The Smith is the odds-on pick for summer wear as I can put it in a pocket holster and wear cargo-type shorts that conceal it and the speed-strip of extra ammo. When I have more clothing on, out comes the Kahr. I have various holsters for it, but lately favor the Versa-Carry device that allows for IWB use without a bulky holster. I have confidnece that I can get the job done with either handgun and the laser sight aids in fast target recognition/aquisition, plus has an intimidation factor.